Wishing You the Best in 2016!
Wednesday, December 30, 2015
Thursday, December 17, 2015
DeKalb Backs Development of GM Factory Site, Awaits Schools Support
By Mark Niesse
Atlanta Journal and Constitution
December 15, 2015
[The Board of Commissioners Credits its Counsel for Structuring an Intergovernmental Agreement that Provides Adequate Safeguards to Protect the County's Interest. To view the discussion, click here.]
Ambitious plans to rejuvenate a closed-down General Motors factory site cleared a major hurdle Tuesday when the DeKalb County Commission unanimously agreed to invest in the redevelopment effort.
But significant challenges remain before the 165-acre site, located along the Perimeter near I-85, can be transformed into a vibrant mixed-use area with retail shops, office space, housing and parks.
Whether the development moves forward depends on the DeKalb school system’s backing. The financing for the project would use expected increases in property tax revenue to pay for $247 million in infrastructure improvements, but the school system hasn’t signed on.
DeKalb Superintendent Stephen Green said Tuesday he has “serious reservations” about devoting education resources to the Doraville project, known as Assembly.
“Our core business is teaching and learning, and routing revenue away from the classroom … is not in the best interest of the children,” Green said. “We are coming into financial stability, and we’re not necessarily willing to take that risk.”
Green said he’s reluctant to commit public money to speculative development, and similar previous efforts in DeKalb haven’t been successful. He also pointed out that Atlanta Public Schools has struggled with its Beltline development partnership with the city of Atlanta, which has missed payments to the city school system.
Developers have discussed the potential to relieve student overcrowding by building a school on the site, a proposal that didn’t satisfy Green because he said the school system can’t wait years for new construction. He is considering redistricting proposals that would address overcrowding.
School board Chairman Melvin Johnson also has said the area needs more immediate relief, and he won’t make a quick decision.
Supporters of the Assembly development said they’ll work to persuade school board members of the project’s benefit to students and their families.
Part of the agreement approved by the DeKalb Commission requires construction of affordable housing units.
“We’re very excited, and now it’s time to get to work, and of course, we have to be working with the school board,” said Doraville Mayor Donna Pittman after the DeKalb Commission’s vote. “It’s a game-changer for the whole city, the whole county, the whole region.”
City Manager Shawn Gillen said he hopes school officials will come to realize the value of the project.
“We can focus our efforts on the school board, talking with them and trying to get them to a comfort level much in the same way as we did the county,” Gillen said. “We’ve got a lot of work to do yet, but this is a major step forward.”
The DeKalb Commission voted 7-0 to enter into an agreement with the city of Doraville to create a mechanism for public financing known as a tax allocation district, which will fund infrastructure on the site necessary to attract businesses. Those upgrades include a tunnel to the Doraville MARTA station and a street grid.
The site preparations would be funded through $247 million in bonds, paid off over time through taxes collected as property values rise. The DeKalb school district would have to provide more than half of that funding. No existing tax money would be used.
An opponent of the development, former Doraville councilman Tom Hart, told commissioners during their public comment period Tuesday that they should vote it down.
“This is purely a publicly funded project,” Hart said. “We’ll call it a pork project because that’s exactly what it is.”
[With the assistance of Charles Johnson, an attorney with the Atlanta office of Holland & Knight,] the county wrote several protections into its agreement before the vote.
The county government won’t support the project financially unless the county school board also gives its consent, according to the agreement. And the county’s inclusion will automatically end in 10 years unless the commission takes another vote to continue its involvement.
“This development will not occur without the dedication of future tax revenues to improve that site,” said Commissioner Jeff Rader.
Integral Group bought the site from General Motors for $50 million last year after it had been unoccupied since the plant closed in 2008. Erik Pinckney, an executive for Integral, has said public support is “critical” to create a district where businesses want to locate.
Saturday, November 14, 2015
Dine Out With Us in Support of Fisk University!
DINE OUT! |
|
|
Monday, October 26, 2015
In deciding on a Sentence for Tyrone Brooks, Consider His Overall Body of Work.
Any judge who considers an appropriate sentence for Tyrone Brooks should consider his contributions to society.
Throughout our nation’s
history, progressive changes have come about in large part because activists
have worked outside of official channels to create a climate that is more
conducive to those changes. In the words
of Frederick Douglas, “Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did,
and it never will.”
A story is told about Sidney
Hillman, who served for a time as head of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers
Union. After helping Franklin Roosevelt
get elected in the Presidential campaign of 1932, Hillman is said to have gone
to the White House and presented an ambitious agenda of progressive actions for
the new President to take. President
Roosevelt supposedly replied: “Sidney, I agree with everything in your proposal.
It is all exactly right. Now you just go
back home and make me do it.”
Years later, Martin Luther
King, Jr. is said to have had a similar conversation with President Lyndon
Johnson. In response to Dr. King’s call
for voting rights legislation and for the appointment of more African American officials,
President Johnson is said to have challenged Dr. King to essentially “make me
do it”.
In more recent times,
Representative Tyrone Brooks has played a role similar to that of Sidney
Hillman and Martin Luther King. With
little thought for his own personal needs, he has worked outside of official
channels to create a climate which made it easier for public officials to do
the right thing. This letter provides just two examples.
When I first began practicing
law, all of Georgia’s trial court judges were white, and few if any were
female, and subsequent progress toward a more representative judiciary was initially
very slow. Through his work with the
American Civil Liberties Union to challenge the method in which Georgia’s
judges were selected, Tyrone Brooks helped to create an environment in which
Governors Zell Miller and Roy Barnes were able through the appointment process
to make our State’s judiciary (at least for a time) dramatically more
representative of the communities that it serves. The work toward a more representative
judiciary continues to this day in our State, and I can personally testify that
Representative Brooks remains a key ally.
Another example: For years,
the people of Georgia were officially represented by a State Flag that was
adopted as part of the State’s historic campaign of “massive resistance”
against court-ordered desegregation.
Tyrone Brooks played a key role in raising awareness of the Flag’s
sordid history. It is largely through
the efforts of people like Representative Brooks that Georgians now have a much
more inclusive Official Symbol that no longer celebrates insurrection or the
elevation of one group over another.
I am not too proud to say that
I a beneficiary of the work of people like Tyrone Brooks. Like many of my contemporaries, I have been
able to take advantage of opportunities which might not have existed without
the work of activists who have opened doors that they themselves never passed
through.
As one considers a sentence for
Representative Brooks, consideration should be given to his overall body of work, which
on balance has significantly contributed toward making our world a better place
Friday, June 26, 2015
Holland & Knight Diversity Week: Profiles in Excellence
From Holland & Knight's "In the Spotlight"
June 26, 2015
About Charles S. Johnson: Charles is a trial lawyer and counselor. He
joined Holland & Knight in 1997.
Tell me how you believe you expand your comfort zone with respect to diversity and inclusion? I’m a product of a segregated environment and, like most of us, I continue to live in an environment that is still characterized by a significant amount of racial and cultural isolation. The workplace is a principal venue for cross-cultural interaction, a place where any level of functional success requires an ability to meet people where they are without forgetting who I am. As an associate, that meant speaking up for myself (through regular and irregular channels) in seeking the amount and kind of work that I felt was necessary to secure appropriate professional development. As a partner, it has meant speaking up for policies and practices that ensure that the firm maximizes its return on investment in all of its diverse talent and doing what I can personally to ensure the equitable allocation of professional development opportunities.
Tell me how you believe you expand your comfort zone with respect to diversity and inclusion? I’m a product of a segregated environment and, like most of us, I continue to live in an environment that is still characterized by a significant amount of racial and cultural isolation. The workplace is a principal venue for cross-cultural interaction, a place where any level of functional success requires an ability to meet people where they are without forgetting who I am. As an associate, that meant speaking up for myself (through regular and irregular channels) in seeking the amount and kind of work that I felt was necessary to secure appropriate professional development. As a partner, it has meant speaking up for policies and practices that ensure that the firm maximizes its return on investment in all of its diverse talent and doing what I can personally to ensure the equitable allocation of professional development opportunities.
How has expanding your comfort zone impacted or changed you?
I am fortunate that, as a younger lawyer, several senior lawyers took an
interest in my success, and I have tried to take full advantage of this
interest. I remember one senior lawyer in particular, to whom I was not
regularly assigned and whose race was not the same as mine, who facilitated a
discussion about the kind of work I was doing. It seems so simple now, but it’s
important: I took the opportunity which this discussion afforded me to indicate
that I wanted more than mere research opportunities, that I wanted the
opportunity to manage cases and try them. As a result of this encounter, I was
afforded opportunities that might not have come to me otherwise, and the result
has been that I have been able to exercise a level of control over the direction
of my own professional development.
Did you have any key mentors or people who deeply influenced who you
are, what you believe in and what you’re committed to in your work and
life? I grew up surrounded by people who had an abiding commitment to
social justice, each of whom pursued that commitment in his or her own unique
way. It never really occurred to me that there was any other way to approach
life. While in college, I got to know Judge Constance Baker Motley and study her
career. Through Judge Motley, I got to know John Lewis, who introduced me to
Atlanta and to the community of people who in the 1960s were changing the world
and who in the 1970s would begin to change Atlanta. My college dean steered me
to the law school that Father Robert Drinan was transforming at Boston College,
and my law school dean steered me toward the law review and the institutional
practice of law. Philip Alston, a senior partner at my first law firm, went out
of his way to let me know that his firm valued its service both to the firm’s
clients and to the community, both of which were to be pursued with
professionalism and integrity.
What is your favorite book/movie? The Arc of
Justice by Kevin Boyle. It’s a true story that touches upon so many things
that are of interest: race relations in 19th-century Lakeland, Fla.; the history
of Wilberforce University and Howard University College of Medicine; the
influence of the Klan in early 20th-century Detroit (a city which is home to my
wife and several friends and clients); and the role of Clarence Darrow in the
first major piece of litigation brought by the NAACP Legal Defense Fund. It’s
great reading, and I recommend it.
When you are not at work, what would we most likely find you doing?
Cycling, working for an accountable and representative judiciary,
supporting Bard College and its diverse and wide-ranging initiatives, supporting
families affected with sickle cell disease, and communing with my own
family.
What are people most surprised to learn about you? I’ve gone
through life with a hearing impairment, with total hearing loss in one
ear.
Thursday, May 21, 2015
ProMedica Decision Enables Aggressive Approach to Hospital Merger Enforcement
From Fierce Hospital Impact
May 20th, 2015
In
their effort to slow the pace of hospital consolidations, federal
regulators have taken a new approach that has led to increased success.
The Supreme Court recently declined to review the application of this
new approach, suggesting that it will continue to be employed for the
foreseeable future, with far-reaching consequences for the healthcare
industry.
Since the early 1980s, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has
challenged hospital mergers that it believed to be anticompetitive,
often successfully blocking such mergers before they were even
consummated.
In the late 1990s, however, the FTC lost eight straight hospital
merger challenges, either due to the its failure to establish the
relevant market, its inability to convince the courts that the predicted
anticompetitive effects would ever materialize, or due to a perception
that a not-for-profit hospital's conduct is driven only by benign
intentions.
In 2002 the FTC announced a "merger retrospective," examining
consummated hospital mergers to ascertain their actual effects on
competition, after which it emerged with a new approach to merger
enforcement. The commission resolved to challenge completed mergers,
where the effects were demonstrable, rather than seeking to enjoin
mergers before they were completed, and to focus on the bargaining power
of each hospital system in its negotiations with managed care
organizations (MCOs). This new approach placed the FTC on a path to
renewed success, and it opened the doors to additional developments,
including private treble-damage class actions.
Recent challenges
In 2004, the FTC challenged a 2000 merger in the Northern Chicago
suburbs between the two-unit Evanston Northwestern Healthcare and
Highland Park Hospital. There were no other hospitals located within the
triangle formed by the three merging hospitals, although each hospital
was within close driving distance of numerous other hospitals.
An administrative law judge (ALJ) concluded that the merger was
unlawful (noting that Evanston's executives had written of their hope
that the merger would increase their bargaining power with MCOs, and
noting that the post-merger rate increases charged by the merged
hospitals exceeded the rate increases for other hospitals in the area).
The full commission left the merged firm intact, but it ordered separate
negotiating teams to bargain with MCOs, one team for the two original
Evanston hospitals and a separate team for Highland Park. After the
FTC's decision, a U.S. District Court certified what may be the first
private class action in a hospital merger case.
Following its Evanston playbook, the FTC in 2011 filed a complaint challenging the 2010 merger of two of the four hospitals in Lucas County, Ohio:
ProMedica, a multi-hospital system, and St. Luke's, an independent
community hospital. Prior to the merger, ProMedica had the largest share
of the general acute care market (46.8 percent), and St. Luke's had the
smallest share (11.5 percent). Since 2000, every MCO network included
either ProMedica or St. Luke's. The merged system commanded 50 percent
of the relevant product market for the so-called "clusters" of primary
services (such as hernia surgeries and radiology services) and secondary
services (such as hip replacements and bariatric surgery), and 80
percent of the separate "cluster" of obstetrical services (which were
excluded from the classification of
primary services).
The ALJ found that the merger resulted in "a tremendous increase in
concentration in a market that was already highly concentrated"; that
the elimination of competition between ProMedica and St. Luke's would
increase ProMedica's bargaining power with MCOs; that the merged entity
would be particularly dominant in an area of the county with a high
proportion of privately insured patients; and that the merger would thus
allow ProMedica unilaterally to increase its prices above a competitive
level. The ALJ ultimately determined that the merger did not create sufficient efficiencies to offset its anticompetitive effects.
The Supreme Court weights in
After the full commission and the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals
affirmed the ALJ's decision to unwind the merger, ProMedica sought
Supreme Court review. ProMedica's lawyers challenged the FTC's use of
"cluster" market analysis; emphasized the relative weakness of the
acquired hospital; and challenged the analysis of market effects, which
combined unilateral effects (i.e., the ability to command monopoly
prices) and collaborative effects (the increase in market
concentration). On May 1, 2015, the Supreme Court issued its decision
declining to review the case.
The Supreme Court's ProMedica decision suggests that the FTC will
persist in the new approach to hospital mergers that emerged after its
2002 "merger retrospective." The FTC will target mergers by dominant
hospital systems that increase the merged system's bargaining power in
negotiations with MCOs, even though this increased bargaining power is a
major factor driving the recent consolidation trend. The lack of a
pre-merger challenge will bring little comfort to merging systems,
especially when a post-merger challenge may be more successful. The
specter of private class actions further increases the stakes for those
considering hospital system mergers.
Charles S. Johnson III is a seasoned trial lawyer with Holland
& Knight in Atlanta. Mr. Johnson primarily focuses in the areas of
public policy and complex business disputes. He has extensive experience with antitrust litigation, and he previously served as adjunct professor of antitrust law
at the University of Georgia Law School.
Saturday, May 16, 2015
Supreme Court Limits Protectionism by State Licensing Boards
Boards Comprised of Active Market Participants Are Not Entitled to Immunity from Federal Antitrust Law Unless They
Are Actively Supervised by the State.
By Charles S. Johnson, Cody Wiggington and Robert Highsmith
From Holland & Knight Health Care & Life Sciences Alert
March 3, 2015
HIGHLIGHTS:
- A new Supreme Court decision reaffirms the two-part Midcal/Ticor test of state action immunity.
- This Supreme Court decision makes it clear that, if a state delegates its regulatory authority to a specialized board that is dominated by active market participants, antitrust immunity is available only if the state exercises a continuing role in the work of the board and actively supervises the board’s work.
- The Supreme Court held that a state board on which a controlling number of decision-makers are active market participants in the occupation that the board regulates must have active state supervision to invoke Parker immunity.
The
United States Supreme Court’s recent decision in N.C. State Bd. of Dental
Examiners v. Federal Trade Commission, No. 13-534, 2015 WL 773331 (S.Ct. February
25, 2015) makes clear that the anticompetitive actions of state regulatory
boards controlled by active market participants not actively supervised by the
state are not entitled to state action immunity from federal antitrust law.
In
N.C. State Bd. of Dental Examiners, the Federal Trade Commission filed
an administrative complaint against the North Carolina State Board of Dental
Examiners alleging the board's concerted action to exclude non-dentists from
the teeth whitening services market in North Carolina constituted an
anticompetitive and unfair method of competition in violation of federal
antitrust laws. After a series of administrative hearings and appeals, the case
made it to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Objections to Services by Unlicensed Providers Required
Filing a Lawsuit
By
way of background, the state has delegated the regulation of dentistry to the
board, whose principal duty is to create, administer and enforce a licensing
system for dentists. The board's authority with respect to unlicensed persons,
however, is limited to filing a lawsuit to enjoin a person from unlawfully
practicing dentistry. Under North Carolina law, the board's eight members must
be licensed dentists engaged in the active practice of dentistry. They are
elected by other licensed dentists in North Carolina, who cast their ballots in
elections conducted by the board.
In
the early years of providing teeth whitening services in North Carolina,
licensed dentists earned substantial fees for the service. Eventually,
non-dentists began offering the service at lower prices. The increased
competition resulted in dentists complaining to the board about the
non-dentists providing teeth whitening services. Notably, most of the
complaints focused on the problem with non-dentists offering lower prices – not
possible harm to consumers.
In
reaction to the complaints, the board issued at least 47 cease and desist
letters to non-dentist teeth whitening service providers and product
manufacturers, prompted the North Carolina Board of Cosmetic Art Examiners to
warn cosmetologists against providing teeth whitening services, and sent
letters to mall operators advising them to expel teeth whitening kiosk
operators from their premises. As a result of the board’s actions, non-dentists
ceased offering teeth whitening services in North Carolina.
Federal Antitrust Laws Are Designed to Promote Competition
During
the administrative and court proceedings, the board argued its members were
invested by North Carolina with the power of the state and that, as a result,
the board's actions were immune from liability under federal antitrust laws.
Once
the case was before the Supreme Court, the court noted that federal antitrust
laws serve to promote robust competition. Meanwhile, the U.S. federal system
empowers the states to pursue their own and the public's welfare. The states
need not maintain an environment of unregulated competition. States often need
to regulate their economies in ways that may be inconsistent with maintaining
such an environment. For example, in some spheres states benefit from limiting
competition to advance the public good. For these reasons, the court in Parker
v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943) held the states, when acting in their
sovereign capacity, enjoy immunity for anticompetitive conduct under federal
antitrust laws. This type of immunity is frequently referred to as Parker or
state action immunity. The availability of this immunity has long been measured
according to the following formula: A state law or regulatory scheme “cannot be
the basis for antitrust immunity unless, first, the State has articulated a
clear policy to allow the anticompetitive conduct and, second, the State
provides active supervision of [the] anticompetitive conduct.” FTC v. Ticor
Title Ins. Co, 504 U.S. 621, 631 (1992) (citing California Liquor
Retail Dealers Association v. Midcal Aluminum, 445 U.S. 97, 105 (1980)).
Supreme Court Addresses Active Supervision
However,
in Hallie v. Eau Claire, 471 U.S. 34 (1985), the Supreme Court suggested
that the requirement of active supervision may in some circumstances be
excused. Relying on the Hallie decision, the North Carolina Dental
Examination Board did not contend that it was actively supervised and further
contended that it was immune even in the absence of such supervision. Rejecting
this claim, the court noted a distinction between two different types of state
actor:
- a prototypical state agency that is accountable to the electorate and possesses general regulatory powers but has no price-fixing agenda
- a specialized board dominated by active market participants
Because
the second type of state actor is more akin to a private trade association with
regulatory authority, and with economic incentives to restrain competition, the
court determined that this type of state actor must be actively supervised.
To
satisfy the requirement of active supervision, the court observed that state
officials must possess and exercise power to review the particular anticompetitive
acts of private parties and disapprove those that fail to accord with state
policy. The “mere potential for state supervision is not an adequate substitute
for a decision by the State.” Daily involvement by the state in an agency's
operations is not required to satisfy the second requirement. It is only
important that the state’s involvement provide a “realistic assurance” that the
anticompetitive conduct of an actor such as the board “promotes state policy,
rather than merely the party's individual interests.” The court accordingly
identified three requirements of active supervision:
- The state supervisor must review the substance of the anticompetitive decision, not merely the procedures followed to produce it.
- The state supervisor must have the power to veto or modify particular decisions to ensure they accord with state policy.
- The state supervisor may not itself be an active market participant.
With
regard to the board’s argument that entities designated by the states as
agencies are exempt from the second requirement, the Supreme Court stated the
board’s assertion does not comport with the court's repeated conclusion that
the need for supervision turns on the risk that active market participants will
pursue their private interests – not on the formal designation given to
regulators by states. The Supreme Court also stated active market participants
controlling state agencies, like the board, creates the risk that the second
requirement was designed to prevent.
The
court noted that the board took the anticompetitive actions without active
supervision by the state and without state ratification, endorsement, or other
approval. With no active supervision by the state, North Carolina state
officials may not have been aware that the board concluded teeth whitening
constitutes “the practice of dentistry” and that the board sought to prohibit
non-dentists from providing such services.
The court, therefore, held that a state board on which a controlling number of decision-makers are active market participants in the occupation that the board regulates must have active state supervision to invoke Parker immunity.
Clear Court Guidance on Retaining Protection of State Action
Immunity
The
Supreme Court’s decision reaffirms the two-part Midcal/Ticor test
of state action immunity. While the court in Hallie had suggested that
immunity was available without a showing of active supervision, several
decisions after Hallie affirmed the active supervision requirement. See,
e.g., Ticor supra; FTC v. Phoebe Putney Health System, Inc.,
133 S.Ct. 1003 (2013). Rather than overrule Hallie, the court limited
its holding by narrowly limiting the circumstances under which the active
supervision requirement will be excused.
The
Supreme Court established fairly clear guidance as to what regulators must do
to retain the protection of state action immunity: If a state delegates its
regulatory authority to a specialized board that is dominated by active market
participants, the state must exercise a continuing role in the work of the
board by actively supervising the board’s work in the manner outlined by the
court.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)